Three Critical Questions for the New Starbucks CEO Brian Niccol

As we all know, Starbucks hired a new CEO last week. They hired Chipotle CEO Brian Niccol to replace beleaguered CEO Laxman Narasimhan.  Niccol faces many challenges as the company has experienced declining revenues, frustrated customers, and disgruntled employees.  As a loyal customer (albeit also a frustrated one) and a close observer of the company, I've been considering the questions that Niccol must grapple with as he embarks on this transformation effort.  Here are three key questions:

1.  How much customization can Starbucks offer to its customers?  Give the customers what they want, right?  Customers clearly love to customize their drinks (in far more complex ways than Chipotle faces).  However, it has become abundantly clear that many Starbucks cafes are unable to effectively handle their throughput each day, particularly given the intense amount of customization they must deliver.  We've read about or experienced long wait times, abandoned orders, and incorrect drink orders.  Mass customization only works if a company can actually deliver on its promises.  One might argue that Niccol simply has to figure it out, and that he has to improve operational efficiency so that Starbucks can offer abundant customization.  However, Niccol also has to think about the practical implications of this strategy.  Should he curtail customization at all while he tries to figure out the operational challenges in the cafes?  I'm reminded of the story of Lego's turnaround twenty years ago, led by CEO Jorgen Vig Knudstorp (see HBS case study by Jan Rivkin and Stefan Thomke for details on this story).  He took charge when Lego faced the prospect of bankruptcy.  The number of parts produced by the company had doubled in the late 1990s, leading to numerous manufacturing and supply chain problems.  Knudstorp reduced the number of parts substantially so as to help the company gets its operations back in order.  At the same time, he invested heavily in innovation.  Lego came roaring back stronger than ever.  Niccol might want to study that turnaround as he considers the customization challenges at Starbucks.  

2.  How will the design (or redesign) of cafes balance worker efficiency vs. customer comfort/needs?  Longtime Starbucks CEO Howard Schultz envisioned the cafes as a "Third Place" where people could gather with others either to enjoy a friendly conversation or to get work done.  However, many of the cafes were designed to handle much less volume than they currently receive.  Workers are in each other's way, and they lack the equipment needed to handle as many orders as they receive.  In one of my local Starbucks cafes, they have renovated completely.  Now, the workers have more equipment (two espresso stations rather than one) and more space.  Undoubtedly, the set-up is much more efficient, and wait times will hopefully decline as a result.   However, customers have less places to sit and gather with others.  No tables are within reach of outlets at this point, reducing the ability to work at the cafes.  You can clearly see the tradeoffs that Starbucks must grapple with in their design choices.  Niccol has to determine the appropriate balance here between enhanced efficiency vs. "Third Place" dynamics.  

3.  How will Niccol handle the shadow of longtime CEO Howard Schultz?  We all know the story by now of how Schultz has returned twice after his initial resignation as CEO in 2000.  We also know that he has opined about the challenges his successors have faced, and he's done so in a very public way at times.  Most recently, he took to LinkedIn to criticize the efforts of CEO Laxman Narasimhan.  Niccol will have to think about how to engage Schultz.  He clearly has a great deal of influence, though he no longer serves on the Board of Directors.  Niccol can't allow Schultz to dictate strategy, but he cannot ignore him completely.