Tuesday, August 02, 2011

McGraw-Hill - Breaking up is hard to do

The Wall Street Journal reports that Jana Partners (a hedge fund) and the Ontario Teachers' Pension Plan have increased their equity stake in McGraw-Hill and may be pushing the company to break up in the near future.  I found the news quite interesting, because it's been apparent for quite some time that the whole was not worth more than the sum of the parts.  Last year, a team of my first-year MBA students performed a strategic analysis of McGraw-Hill for their course project.  They concluded that McGraw-Hill's businesses did not fit together.  The company operates a financial services unit, which includes the S&P credit rating agency.  It also operates a large, but struggling, education unit (which sells textbooks, for example), and it has several television stations in its portfolio.   McGraw-Hill divested Business Week last year.   The synergies among these varied units are rather limited.  

Of course, investors have known this for some time, as has the management team.  Even a team of first-year MBAs could see rather easily that one had a hard time justifying this strategy given the limited economies of scope.  Yet, the company has remained intact.   It shows how difficult it can be for management to break up a company... particularly one that has a long and storied history of family ownership and leadership.   Chairman and Chief Executive Harold McGraw III's great-grandfather founded the company in 1888.  I'm sure that the family legacy makes it difficult to ponder breaking up the firm.  One reason for that may be that a break-up might put the company in play.   Firms may swoop in to try to acquire the various parts, and the firm may have a hard time remaining independent and family-controlled.  

1 comment:

Rudra455 said...

We facilitate the provision of independent analysis to support expert testimony, regulatory or legislative engagements. Frequently, this work includes economic, financial and statistical studies of varying data analysis, technical and http://www.towervideophoto.com.