Monday, December 18, 2017

How Expertise Can Become a Liability

Andras Tilcsik and Juan Almandoz published an interesting article in the Rotman Business School's management magazine this year titled, "When Expertise Becomes a Liability."  They studied over 1,300 banks during the 1996-2012 time period.  124 of those banks failed (slightly less than 10%).  In conditions of decision uncertainty, having more domain experts on the board of the bank meant a higher probability of failure.  They argue that having some domain experts is important and essential,  but there can be too much of a good thing.  Having a few people with expertise in other domains can be quite beneficial.  

Why the liability of expertise?  They argue that a high proportion of domain experts on a board leads to three problems.  First, domain experts can be very entrenched in their views, and they may be unwilling to look at issues in new ways as the environment changes.   Second, domain experts may exhibit high degrees of overconfidence in terms of their ability to make projections and forecasts.  Finally, a high proportion of domain experts might be associated with a lack of constructive conflict and debate within the board.  Why?  Non-experts may be unwilling to challenge conventional wisdom, ask tough questions, or offer dissenting views if they are greatly outnumbered by domain experts on the board.  

2 comments:

Janice In Udaipur Escort Service said...

Welcome to guys I am Janice Independent Escort in Udaipur My figure Nice Looking so Beautiful Independent Escort girl in Udaipur..

Udaipur Escort
Escort Service Udaipur
Udaipur Escort Service
Udaipur Call Girls

Agra Escort Service
Agra Escort
Escort Service In Agra
Agra Call Girls

Jaipur Escort Service
Jaipur Escort
Escort Service In Jaipur
Jaipur Call girls

Jaipur Escort Service
Jaipur Escort
Escort Service In Jaipur
Jaipur Call girls

Jaipur Escort Service
Jaipur Escort
Escort Service In Jaipur
Jaipur Call girls

Shilpa Escorts said...


thanks for sharing this post.. if you want more pleasure services Selection and slant of clients vary starting with one then onto the next hence to please and attract in every consumer we possess the occasion to serve we promise we now have those Telephone jaipur call girls with us to facilitate using the air of just about every guy..