Tuesday, July 24, 2018

Should You Hire for Cultural Fit or Not?

For decades, executives have stressed the importance of hiring for cultural fit.  You often hear discussions about cultural fit among people on recruitment and selection committees, as well as by people working for executive search firms.   Recently, though, Adam Grant of the Wharton School has made an important point about the downside of hiring for cultural fit, and he's received a great deal of attention for his thought-provoking and insightful comments.  Here's what Grant has said, as reported in an interview with Dan Schawbel for Fortune

First, stop hiring on cultural fit. That’s a great way to breed groupthink. Emphasizing cultural fit leads you to bring in a bunch of people who think in similar ways to your existing employees. There’s evidence that once a company goes public, those that hire on cultural fit actually grow more slowly because they struggle to innovate and change. It’s wiser to follow the example from the design firm IDEO, and hire on cultural contribution. Instead of looking for people who fit the culture, ask what’s missing from your culture, and select people who can bring that to the table.

Is he right?  I htink he makes a strong argument for avoiding groupthink.  Managers do have a very unfortunate tendency to hire people who look, think, and act much as they do.  To be effective, leaders need to consider hiring people who think differently, who complement and augment their own skills and abilities (rather than replicating the expertise and modes of thinking already on the team).   

Having said that, I think there are some important aspects of "fit" that need to be considered when hiring.  Otherwise, new employees will either face organ rejection at their new firms, or they will have an adverse impact on the organization's effectiveness.  First and foremost, it's very important to make sure that a new hire shares the same values as the organization he or she will be joining.  Second, does the new hire believe in the mission of the enterprise?  Do they feel passionately about the organization's purpose?   They may have different views about the means to achieve those objectives.  That's healthy.   Finally, will the person's leadership approach enable others to succeed?  Hopefully, the hiring organization has leaders in place who have created a safe place where others can speak up, discuss mistakes, express dissent, and ask challenging questions.   New hires have to be able to create a safe climate for their employees as well.  If they a history of acting in ways that discourage others from speaking up, then they won't "fit" and they will have an adverse impact on the organization's effectiveness.  

2 comments:

Marc Scrivener said...

Hiring is the most effective means by which an organization can change its' culture, so when I hire--I'm looking more for someone who reflects the culture we want to have in our organization. The Attraction--Selection--Attrition (ASA) model suggests that we have to be careful not to hire someone too radically different from the current culture. Culture change is gradual, unless an organization loses a lot of their legacy employees in a short time frame.

viswanath said...

AWS Training in Bangalore - Live Online & Classroom
myTectra Amazon Web Services (AWS) certification training helps you to gain real time hands on experience on AWS. myTectra offers AWS training in Bangalore using classroom and AWS Online Training globally. AWS Training at myTectra delivered by the experienced professional who has atleast 4 years of relavent AWS experince and overall 8-15 years of IT experience. myTectra Offers AWS Training since 2013 and retained the positions of Top AWS Training Company in Bangalore and India.

IOT Training in Bangalore - Live Online & Classroom
IOT Training course observes iot as the platform for networking of different devices on the internet and their inter related communication. Reading data through the sensors and processing it with applications sitting in the cloud and thereafter passing the processed data to generate different kind of output is the motive of the complete curricula. Students are made to understand the type of input devices and communications among the devices in a wireless media.