Of course, some leaders are exceptional in many ways. That does not mean that we should come to the conclusion that no one else can do a good job at the helm. We can believe that they exhibit highly distinctive talents, and yet still focus on the fact that someone else with different talents could do an outstanding job leading the organization.
I would argue that the myth of irreplaceability can become very dangerous BEFORE a long-time CEO departs. Subordinates can defer to easily and quickly to their judgments and conclusions, thereby refraining from expressing dissenting views. The leaders themselves can exhibit overconfidence and dismiss warning signs that trouble lies ahead. Moreover, they can fail to acknowledge their own weaknesses and the gaps in their expertise. These challenges can lead to problems long before the leader's departure. Sometimes, those problems do not rear their ugly head until years later, when the successor bears the brunt of the criticism for those failures.
Quigley goes on to write about succession planning, which is a critical process that the board must own:






