Wednesday, November 18, 2026

The Irreplaceable CEO? Dangerous Thinking for Boards, Leaders, and Organizations

Source: Reuters
In the wake of the Jensen Huang scandal at Nvidia, we should take a moment to think about the myth of the irreplaceable CEO. Too often, highly successful leaders, particularly founders, come to believe that they are irreplaceable. They are not alone. The board comes to that conclusion as well. This type of thinking can be dangerous for an organization. In a terrific essay, IMD's Tim Quigley writes the following:

There are serious downsides to mythologizing the founder of your company. The first is that the business may be tied too closely to their personality, opinions, and preferences. When founders leave, the attention goes with them. This can lead to broken cultures, lost relationships, and the loss of key talent who might follow the leader out the door. The successor also inherits a valuation that was partly built on perception of personality rather than results and then gets burdened for its decay as though it were an operating failure.

Of course, some leaders are exceptional in many ways.  That does not mean that we should come to the conclusion that no one else can do a good job at the helm. We can believe that they exhibit highly distinctive talents, and yet still focus on the fact that someone else with different talents could do an outstanding job leading the organization.

I would argue that the myth of irreplaceability can become very dangerous BEFORE a long-time CEO departs.  Subordinates can defer to easily and quickly to their judgments and conclusions, thereby refraining from expressing dissenting views.  The leaders themselves can exhibit overconfidence and dismiss warning signs that trouble lies ahead.  Moreover, they can fail to acknowledge their own weaknesses and the gaps in their expertise.  These challenges can lead to problems long before the leader's departure.  Sometimes, those problems do not rear their ugly head until years later, when the successor bears the brunt of the criticism for those failures. 

Quigley goes on to write about succession planning, which is a critical process that the board must own:

An inability to accept their own replaceability could point to a narcissist in the CEO’s chair. But some CEOs could simply lack the specialist skills to plan for a future under a different leader. Nevertheless, it ultimately remains their responsibility...Rather than focusing on founders’ supposedly rare and irreplicable talents, boards and shareholders would be better served by holding founders to account for recognizing their own limitations and finding future leaders who have skills the founder is missing. Relieved of the belief that the current leader can’t be replaced, one can then naturally get on with the business of talent development and succession planning that seems pointless if you believe a leader is really irreplaceable.

Thursday, November 12, 2026

"Passing the Mic" May Help You Get Promoted...but Why?


Are cooperative members of the executive leadership team more likely to be promoted to CEO of the company?  Yes, according to an interesting new study by Columbia Business School Professor Wei Cai and her co-authors.  

The scholars studied more than 78,000 earnings call transcripts from 2010-2020. They focused on the question-and-answer portion of the conference calls. They identified approximately 130,000 occasions in which executives "passed the mic" to one another. During these interactions, an executive invited one of their peers into the conversation, perhaps asking them to offer more details about a particular topic. The scholars described these moments as "cooperative interactions." The scholars summarized their findings:

"Older, more senior, and more experienced executives are more likely to display cooperativeness. We also find that cooperativeness persists but can be influenced by colleagues. Turning to the relation with career and firm outcomes, we find robust evidence of a positive association between cooperativeness and the likelihood of being promoted to CEO."

The scholars also found that the capital markets responded positively when a cooperative executive became CEO.   Cai explains, "The market seems to interpret a cooperative leader as a positive signal about a firm's organizational effectiveness and value creation.”

I find these results to be extremely interesting.  I wonder, though, if there may be an alternative explanation for these findings.  Perhaps the leaders who are more likely to be promoted tend to exhibit more intellectual humility.  They are more likely not to speak about subjects about which they do not have deep expertise.  They are effective at acknowledging gaps in their own expertise, and then seeking out knowledge and information from those around them.  They are willing to ask for help! In short, they are better at getting to the right answers by understanding that they don't have all the answers themselves. 

Monday, November 02, 2026

When Leaders Change Their Minds

Source: https://esternicholson.wordpress.com

Successful business leaders change their minds at times. They do not simply stick to a plan even if it is failing. They do not throw good money after bad. As Art Markman writes in Fast Company, "In a dynamic world, though, opinions, beliefs, and plans should change as new information becomes available."  Yet, leaders are often criticized harshly and branded as "flip-floppers" when they shift their positions on an issue.  

In a 2017 study, Tamara Kreps and her co-authors conducted a series of experiments focused on how we perceive leaders who change their opinions.  They compared people who based their initial position on pragmatic rationale vs. a moral one.  They concluded, "We find that audiences believe moral commitments should not be broken, and thus that they deride as hypocritical leaders who claim a moral commitment and later change their views. Moreover, they view them as less effective and less worthy of support. Although participants found a moral mind changer especially hypocritical when they disagreed with the new view, the effect persisted even among participants who fully endorsed the new view."

How should you handle a shift in positions so as to maintain your credibility as a leader?  Markman argues that leaders need to be ready for criticism, but prepared to explain both their original rationale as well as the reasons why they changed their minds.  Many leaders try to do that, of course, yet they still face skepticism and doubts.  I would argue that leaders need to do three things when announcing a change to a previous decisions:

1. They must be extremely clear about the assumptions that were made at the time of the original decision.  Then, leaders should talk about why some of those assumptions may have been proven invalid.  

2. Leaders should talk about the information that was used to make the original decision, and then they should explain how specific updated information caused them to change their positions and beliefs.  

3. Leaders should identify changes in the external environment that shifted the context considerably. Then, they should explain how the original plan no longer fit the environmental conditions.